How to Plan the Perfect Surprise Proposal on Catalina Island
Catalina Island is one of California’s most romantic destinations, offering breathtaking views, serene beaches, and a touch of adventure—making it the perfect spot to pop the question. As a professional photographer specializing in proposals and engagements, I’ve had the privilege of capturing magical moments on this dreamy island. While there’s no shortage of proposal advice out there, I want to share three key tips that are often overlooked but can make all the difference for your big moment.
1. Contact Your Photographer Early and Share Your Vision
The earlier you reach out to your photographer, the better. Catalina Island is a popular destination, and booking ahead ensures you’ll have a pro available who’s familiar with the island’s best locations. When contacting your photographer, communicate your proposal vision clearly. Are you imagining an intimate moment at Wrigley Memorial, a surprise by the beach, or a scenic shot on a hiking trail? Sharing these details ahead of time allows your photographer to plan logistics, lighting, and angles, so they can capture the moment perfectly.
Pro Tip: If you’re unsure about the exact location, your photographer can offer suggestions based on their expertise. For example, the bridge at Wrigley Memorial offers stunning compositions with the monument as a backdrop, while the Descanso Beach Club provides a more relaxed vibe.
2. Plan the Timeline Thoughtfully
Timing is everything for a surprise proposal. Not only should you consider the time of day for optimal lighting (early afternoon or golden hour is ideal), but also how much time you’ll need before and after the proposal.
Before the Proposal: Allow for time to get to the location without feeling rushed. Catalina’s terrain can be tricky, so plan for the walk, parking, or navigating with a golf cart.
After the Proposal: Consider setting aside at least 30 minutes to an hour for post-proposal photos. This allows you to enjoy the initial excitement while your photographer captures candid, joyful moments. If you’re up for it, you can even plan for a short outfit change or a second location nearby, such as the botanical gardens or your cozy Airbnb.
Pro Tip: Keep in mind that Catalina Island has limited cell service in some areas, so finalize all plans with your photographer before arriving.
3. Get Creative with the Surprise
Every couple’s story is unique, so think about how to make your proposal personal. Whether it’s recreating a meaningful memory, incorporating a small prop, or even pretending to take a selfie before popping the question, there are countless ways to make it special.
For example, Ravi from Boston contacted me after finding one of my blogs. He proposed to Emily, his partner of over a decade, on the bridge at Wrigley Memorial. Despite Emily having food poisoning the night before, they decided to go ahead with the plan—but with a twist. To give Emily time to freshen up, we adjusted the session to include intimate moments at their BnB. She climbed the Wrigley stairs like a champ, radiating joy and love as they celebrated together. The flexibility to change plans last minute turned into an even more beautiful, memorable experience.
Ravi and Emily’s Love Story
Ravi and Emily have been together for over ten years, building a beautiful life together in Boston. When Ravi decided to propose, he scouted Catalina Island months in advance and found my blog, which inspired him to reach out.
The night before the proposal didn’t go as planned—Emily had food poisoning, and Ravi was worried about sticking to their itinerary. After some last-minute adjustments, we incorporated their BNB, Mt Ada, into the session, allowing Emily time to freshen up. She was radiant, joyful, and ready to celebrate, proving that a little flexibility and trust in your photographer can turn challenges into cherished memories.
Proposing on Catalina Island is a magical experience, but the details can make or break the moment. From contacting your photographer early to planning the timeline and personalizing the surprise, these small considerations go a long way. If you’re ready to capture this unforgettable chapter of your love story, I’d love to help you plan the perfect proposal.
Ready to plan your Catalina Island proposal? Contact me at La Petite Photo to make your dream moment come true.
